In the bbc adaptation and original novel there is a noticeable difference in the equality between the two protagonists. In the book sherlock acts as like he is more important than watson, whereas in the bbc version watson stands up for himself. One major difference between the film it seems and the stories is that. Sir arthur conan doyles version of sherlock holmes.
What are the similarities and differences between the movie. Books similar to the complete sherlock holmes the complete sherlock holmes. What are the similarities and differences between the. Similarities and differences between sherlock and watson. I just wanna hear your thoughts if u can idk if i get answers here discussion. Other than the punch, the leaving holmes partnership in crime and how he met his wife mary there is little to no difference between this watson and movie watson. When the first of the sherlock holmes films starring robert downey, jr. The beekeepers apprentice opens in early april 1915, about eight months after the opening of the first world war, when young mary russell stumbles, literally, across retired detective sherlock holmes on the sussex or south downs. A 1983 cartoon sherlock holmes and a study in scarlet with peter otoole as the voice of holmes comes the closest.
Many authors tried to fulfill this needs and a lot of pastiches, parodies and adaptations were produced until today, reaching from book form, movies, tv series, over. The book is a collection of twelve previously published articles for such wellrespected magazines as the new yorker and the atlantic. May 10, 2010 his wife mary didnt really mind since in the books they met through holmes, she was his client in the second book. Comparison and contrast of book and movie about sherlock.
In the popular imagination, the biblical stories of jesus clearing of the temple and withering of the fig tree represent, at best, humorous, bizarre. What are the differences between sherlock holmes from the tv. I have managed to notice some of the similarities and differences between the original story, a study and scarlet, and the television episode, a study in pink. An aged, retired sherlock holmes deals with early dementia, as he tries to remember his final case, and a mysterious woman, whose memory haunts him. I just wanna hear your thoughts if u can idk if i get answers here. The character sherlock holmes is quite a charming fellow. Sherlock says that he is a consulting detective which is a job he made up.
This is not to decide if the movie portrayal is one that we personally. Apart from one being a book and another a series of episodes. If you havent seen the hounds of the baskervilles 1939, check it out. Spoilers for the guy ritchie sherlock holmes movies, for the tv series. Sherlock holmes book and movie comparison by alexis. What is the difference between the movie study in pink and. So i have an essay to write of the difference between the movie sherlock holmes the one with robert downey, jr. Oct 14, 2010 the big difference that i noticed, was that in the movie holmes didnt really seem to know watsons fiance, but in the books sign of the four she was his client and thats how she and watson meet. Jul 15, 2009 guy ritchies sherlock holmes isnt due for release until december, but many fans of the sleuth legend are already upset with what appears to be a slightly piratesofthecaribbean take on the material. The hound of the baskervilles was written by arthur conan doyle in the august 1901,and was published in the strand magazine in april 1902.
A comparison between the stories and the movie german edition 9783656541578. A scandal in belgravia to the adventures of sherlock holmes. Compare and contrast the hound of the baskervilles movie. Baritsu may have been new to the holmes universe, but handtohand combat wasnt. The 2009 film sherlock holmes is a fun version of the famous detective, but not a completely accurate one. They were forerunners of comic books and graphic novels, and their goals. Jul 20, 2015 this is funny, because if you know nothing about sherlock holmes you might think you are watching a biopic about the real man behind the mystery instead of a work of fiction based on a book.
Who played the part of sherlock holmes in sherlock holmes the movie. However, sherlock holmes, the movie, is not based on any of doyles books but on a screenplay by british screenwriters michael robert johnson, anthony peckham, simon kinberg, and lionel wigram. Apr 21, 2014 although there are many differences between a study in pink and a study in scarlet, i would like to focus on the differences in portrayal of the character sherlock holmes and how they affect our view of him as a hero. I have watched the first episode of the bbc sherlock television series, a study in pink. Sherlock most likely has adhd, or at least appears to in the movie. In 1986, a tv movie called my tenderly loved detective was made in soviet union about the adventures of the female sherlock holmes, called shirley holmes. Sherlock holmes was the ultimate logical reasoner in pop culture until mr. The adventures of a scandal in bohemia is a short story that is perfect for all audiences. I think that the creators of bbc sherlock probably took a lot of influence from raffles, including the curly dark hair, more sociopathic attitude, and his loyal. Cumberbatchs holmes is the result of who he was born as, and the life he has led to the time the show begins. How faithful is guy ritchies sherlock holmes to arthur conan. Now both have aired their second instalments, just how do the guy ritchie and moffatgatiss interpretations of sherlock holmes measure up to conan doyles source material.
Sherlock holmes in the movie is so narrowly based on the character in the story that the very small, minimal differences between them do not have any effect on the story. I read a study in scarlet years ago and hated it because of the mormon bits. In the movie, sherlock tends to have a slightly more aggressive approach to things, he is very blunt, and though he is extremely smart, and thinks things through, he still gets caught up in it all. The adventure of a scandal in bohemia moviebook comparison the adventures of a scandal in bohemia is a short story that is perfect for all audiences. The only times people are referred to by their first names is when the people talking have the same surname, like mycroft and sherlock and john and mary. Since this was the first sherlock holmes story, conan doyle seemed to be. He also befriends a fan, the young son of his housekeeper, who wants him to work again. Compare and contrast the hound of the baskervilles movie and book the hound of the baskervilles written by sir arthur conan doyle and the movie the hound of the baskervilles directed by jeremy bret are two works of art that are mainly telling the same story. Everything thats not in canon but people think is although the film is based on characters created by conan doyle except one, but more on that later, its not an adaptation of any case or book from sherlock holmes universe. Nov 18, 2014 i read a study in scarlet before watching episode 1 of the first season of sherlock which is called a study in pink. Sherlock holmes books and movie comparison free download as word doc.
While i love what the new movie has done in bringing out the implied holmes he was a boxer, drug addict and so forth, the holmes that comes across in the books is solving mysteries. There have been numerous modifications made in the television episode to present. There are, however, many differences about the book and the movie. The 10 best sherlock holmes adaptations, according to. It doesnt go far out like the sherlock television series. Sherlocks first appearance was in strand magazine in 1891. The complete collection of sherlock holmess adventures in crime, including all four novels and fiftysix short stories featuring sir arthur conan doyles classic hero volume i includes the early novel a study in scarlet, which introduced the eccentric genius of sherlock. No one can say the guy doesnt get his hands dirty while investigating. The great mouse detective baker street wiki fandom. Benedict cumberbatch as sherlock holmes in the bbcs sherlock. Holmes essay as we start to talk and discuss mystery and its elements today, we will analyze what mystery really means. And make no mistake, it wants to be a franchise the movie leaves off where a sequel could handily pick right up.
How does the 2009 movie sherlock holmes compare to the books. The differences between the character in the book and movie do not enhance the story for a range of reasons. The movie is riddled with occult symbols and allusions to a new order. Comparison and contrast of book and movie about sherlock holmes and watson. In the book, sherlock is witty, calm, resourceful, and full of knowledge. Simply put, no list of holmes mustreads would be complete without the tight but significant story of their battle at the falls of reichenbach. Holmes and watson incapacitate blackwoods henchmen, and watson is behind blackwood, holding him at gunpoint with the revolver in his left hand. How did ritchie put the character of sherlock holmes and all his trappings into a modern context. Apr 21, 2012 the character sherlock holmes is quite a charming fellow.
It contains the earliest short stories featuring the consulting detective sherlock holmes, which had been published in twelve monthly issues of the strand magazine from july 1891 to june 1892. Watson and sherlock are both well rounded characters with large differences that depend on each other in their quests to solve many murder mysteries. Other stories from the memoirs of sherlock holmes to consider adding to your list are the gloria scott, the greek interpreter, and the naval treaty. Then the comparison between the stories and the movie will be drawn, focusing on the plans the filmmakers had, and how they were applied, on details borrowed from the source and changes made, especially watching the characters of sherlock holmes and dr. The movie representation of the protagonist sherlock holmes character, behavior, and the way he reacts to finding clues is similar to the book. There is a movie entitled a study in scarlet from 1933 with reginald owen as sherlock holmes that has nothing to do with the original story. When it was released in 2009, sherlock holmes was a bit of a run away success. Get an answer for what are the similarities and differences between the movie and the story of the redheaded league. This paper will concentrate on a twentyfirstcentury adaptation, namely guy ritchies movie sherlock holmes from 2009, and its fidelity to the source will be examined. Guy ritchies sherlock holmes isnt due for release until december, but many fans of the sleuth legend are already upset with what appears to be a slightly piratesofthecaribbean take on the material.
In the movie, watson says he has a general lack of hygiene, he is not clean shaven, is somewhat. Sherlock has a passion for definite and exact knowledge. Sherlock holmes is a 2009 film that follows the famous detective and his faithful friend watson as they go up against the nefarious lord blackwood and try to demystify his supposed resurrection, all while handling the distractions of an occult group in london, the infamous irene adler, and watsons impending marriage to his dear mary. John watson, holmes takes on strange and challenging cases. The adventures of sherlock holmes is a collection of twelve short stories by arthur conan doyle, first published on 14 october 1892. Sherlock holmes has the sooty, gritty look and feel of bygone london, and ritchie, no surprise, brings out the franchises pugnacious side. This is funny, because if you know nothing about sherlock holmes you might think you are watching a biopic about the real man behind the mystery instead of a work of fiction based on a book. Most people are referred to by their first names with the exception of lestrade, moriarty, anderson and a few others. Sherlock holmes movie to book comparison movie moron. How does the 2009 movie sherlock holmes compare to the. Blackwood then provokes watson, who lunges forward, about to strike with the baton in his right hand. There are twelve pieces in the devil and sherlock holmes. More than 70 actors played the role of sherlock holmes in 200 films. The relationship between sherlock holmes and john watson.
Sherlock holmes 2009 frequently asked questions imdb. The single biggest difference between the two performances of holmes is that bbcs sherlock gives the viewer a holmes that is, while cbs elementary gives us a holmes that has become. Heres watson doing the same, in the adventure of the empty house, while helping his friend out of a tight spot. Now how we define mystery is something that is very different from person to person. In the films, holmes is seen taking on various personas in order to avoid thugs or gather information. The 10 best sherlock holmes movies of all time taste of. Referring to himself as a consulting detective in the stories, holmes is known for his proficiency with observation, deduction, forensic science, and logical reasoning that borders on the fantastic, which he employs when. The same can be said of the subsequent the return of sherlock holmes, the case book of sherlock holmes, and the memoirs of sherlock holmes, each of which showcases bretts studied holmesian brilliance. Why is arthur conan doyles irene adler so much better than the versions crafted by steven moffat and guy ritchie. What are the differences between sherlock holmes from the. The films were entitled sherlock holmes and a study in scarlet, sherlock holmes and the sign of four, sherlock holmes and the baskerville curse, and sherlock holmes and the valley of fear.
Differences between sherlock holmes the movie and the books. On one occasion, in the naval treaty, holmes skulked outside a house for. Surprisingly, there is not much difference between the book and movie. Comparing ritchies sherlock holmes to conan doyles. Such is the case of man ritchies 2009 movie, merely titled sherlock holmes, with robert downey jr. Sherlock holmes comparing the movie and the book hubpages. The great mouse detective is a 1986 disney animated film, based on the childrens book series by eve titus, which was in turn a version of sherlock holmes. Sherlock holmes comparing the movie and the book the main differences between movie and book.
When comparing the sherlock holmes book and the sherlock holmes movie, there are quite a lot of differences and yet many similarities. They also introduce moriarty far earlier than in the books. Many authors tried to fulfill this needs and a lot of pastiches, parodies and adaptations were produced until today, reaching from book form, movies, tvseries, over. Apr 10, 2014 anthony horowitz, who was first sanctioned by the conan doyle estate to tell a new sherlock holmes story three years ago, is plotting a return to the world of the super sleuth in a novel set days. Holmes in the books, teaches watson more about his trade and how he deduces things than he does in the movie. Sherlock holmes is a most portrayed character in history. Honestly, i dont think the movie does justice to the original works. Whats the difference between elementary and sherlock.
Ive read all of the sherlock holmes stories and novels and watched sherlock holmes the one with robert downey junior as holmes, 2009. In our opinions a good mystery novel is something that gives us a crime or murder or something in a sense where we. Jan 23, 2020 the same can be said of the subsequent the return of sherlock holmes, the casebook of sherlock holmes, and the memoirs of sherlock holmes, each of which showcases bretts studied holmesian brilliance. Tv show point of view technology book point of view the bbcs version of sherlock has access to modern technology and is able to solve cases more efficiently, and in. Sherlock holmes is a fictional consulting detective in london 18801914 created by scottish author and physician sir arthur conan doyle. Apr 11, 2011 sherlock holmes had nothing to do with the romance in the hound. The sherlock holmes of the books is often detached and unemotional, but its always clear that he cares about watson. Sherlock holmes returns in new anthony horowitz book. As a bonus, the foley work and sound engineering of these adaptations have a hypnotic asmr crispness.
The film was directed by guy ritchie and produced by joel silver, lionel wigram, susan downey, and dan lin. Sherlock holmes has had a pop culture resurgence in recent years, thanks to robert downey jr. Sherlock holmes is a quirky british detective with an unusually keen eye for detail. The adventure of a scandal in bohemia moviebook comparison. Richmond adams, assistant professor of english at northwestern oklahoma state university, has been fascinated by cinematic adaptations of sherlock holmes throughout the years. There is a certain tenderness in holmes a detached, victorian tenderness.
Sherlock holmes stories by doyle can be classified into long stories and short stories. Its a good film inspired on splendid novels about sherlock holmes character written by arthur conan doyle, including two firstrange nasties with malignant aims as mark strong as blackwood and doctor moriarty, furthermore one woman, rachel mcadams, as a suspicious young with mysterious purports. One major difference between the film it seems and the stories is that many of the action sequences in the text are described after the fact, by holmes or some other witness. Lets focus on the first meeting between sherlock holmes and john watson. Well look at the history of sherlock holmes, the origins of the symbols found in the movie and its meaning in todays context. Ian mckellen, laura linney, hiroyuki sanada, hattie morahan. Holmes is tall, lanky, clean, and wellkept in the books. They both deal with a mystery person or group that is murdering people, but they vary because in the five orange pips the mysterious person is part of the klu klux klan and in the blind banker the mysterious person was. This shows up in the book a study in scarlet but isnt in the show until later in the season. The latest hollywood blockbuster sherlock holmes revolves around occult murders and world conspiracies.
Sherlock holmes, a study in pink i personally believe this alteration has helped in demonstrating a more humane side of the unemotional detective. The hound of the baskervilles difference between the book and. Moving on, ive managed to acknowledge several similarities between a study in scarlet and a study in pink. Differences between sherlock holmes the movie and the. For those who have seen the sherlock holmes movies the first or a game of shadows what do u. Sherlock holmes is a 2009 period mystery action film based on the character of the same name created by sir arthur conan doyle. Sherlock holmes will always be basil rathbone in my mind. Mary russell companion is a compendium released on may 1, 2014 that introduces new fans to the fictional character. The complete novels and stories, volume i from the worlds largest community of readers.
When i saw how much was actually in common between the two, i was blown away by what an amazing job they did of taking the story line and elements from the book and making them modern. The 10 best sherlock holmes movies of all time posted on march 20, 2016 march 20, 2016 by george cromack having been portrayed on screen in excess of two hundred and fifty times, producing any list of film titles featuring sir arthur conan doyles sherlock holmes who first appeared in print in 1887 is no easy task. The movie can represent the book with little differences as the characters and the plot stays as the book. Sherlock holmes is to retrieve a picture for his client, with the help of this good friend dr. Holmes, master of disguise, reasoned logically to deduce clients background from their first appearance. Why cant any recent sherlock holmes adaptation get irene. First broadcast in 1981, this is a great radio play adaption of the novel. Watson, the famous fictional crime fighting duo from the works written by sir arthur conan doyle, both on television and in the movies. How closely do sherlock episodes relate to the original stories. The story revolves around the great mouse detective in question, basil a play on the name of famous holmes actor basil rathbone, and his. What differences are there between sherlock holmes and dr. There have been many interpretations of sherlock holmes and dr.
373 1275 1491 560 1126 522 848 55 1577 377 636 1599 356 357 833 340 1149 977 253 761 706 1100 582 1348 346 895 599 470 1572 1445 372 1514 792 775 1100 254 109 1414 1001 1364 1469 390 136 789